A 2003 saga from the old Quivering Brain site.
This Letter started me thinking and then one thing led to another…
Ok, so here’s what happened. I came home for lunch one day and found this letter on my front door. I opened it and I found the letter attached to this link. I was immediately incensed and then wondered if I was over-reacting. Instead of actually confronting him, like he should have done me, I decided to post my reply on the “internet” and not tell him about it. Unfortunately, my own website is my solitary forum. So here’s his letter and my replies , I had several, and some comments from people I emailed it to. Well, at least nobody got killed. Please, enjoy!
The original note from the neighbor and the replies from friends quote other people, so they are kept in the Members Vault.
Variations On the "Bob’s Letter" Theme
OK, so after posting his letter instead of beating his ass, I got several good responses and ideas for bumper stickers. So here they are:
My Best High Road Rebuttal # 1 · My Best Low Road Rebuttal # 2 · What I Read That He Said # 3
My Best High Road Rebuttal # 1
Bob, you are a self-important intolerant elitist. Why couldn’t you just confront me like a man? It really made me angry to find your note on my door. I never had an agreement with you for when I will run my saws. Implied, agreed or otherwise. I thought you were being unreasonable, presumptive and entirely over-reactive suggesting I must consult with you prior to using my tools. I can’t believe you just couldn’t close your door for a little while. I am a homeowner and I would like to invest in my home from time to time without your interference.
Let me make one thing perfectly clear: I will run any and all my saws when I please and when I see fit without any suggestions from you or any of our other neighbors for whom you seem so willing to offer opinion. I checked with the police department and it is perfectly legal for me to run them between the hours of 8am and 10 pm.
It’s obvious you spent an inordinate amount of time thinking about this and then putting it in writing!?! You put it in writing!! Do you know what that means? I can post it anywhere and let others see how ridiculous and overbearing you are. This simply proves what a unthinking dope you are. I now control the text of your message and its distribution, You’ve somehow justified your repression of others natural human behaviors in order to meet your own peculiar personal needs. You’ve tried to it within some new-agey touchy-feely words but is still boils down to unrealistic expectations of your environment and the behavior of those around you.
It seems to me that you have some irrational need for a quiet “working” environment. To me this is an extreme non-issue. To others it might suggest paranoia or criminal activity. Might I suggest earplugs or environmental soundproofing of your own home? Since you are already a soundproofing expert, why are you wasting time telling me how to do it? It just doesn?t make sense for you to just sit there when you could just soundproof your way to happiness. You have no real interest in me as a human being with my own needs trying to achieve my own personal liberty and goals as a individual. You care not that I may want to improve my home by building shelves in my spare time. I understand, being a renter such as yourself, you may not care to improve the value of someone else’s home like the one you live in. But since I actually OWN my home, I feel a great need to improve it. You act as if I just go out every day and start up the saws for the sole purpose if torturing my neighbors. It’s obvious you’ve never felt the sheer joy in creating wooden objects from scratch and actually use them in your own home. Yours is the first complaint I’ve had in 35 years of public and private saw-using.
Bob, you need to understand my perspective. To begin with, the central value in my choice system is individual freedom. By freedom I mean exactly and only freedom from coercion by others. Self-annointed arbiters of correct human behavior seldom concern themselves with the loss of individual freedom. Just as you said, “I also feel that we all need to take responsibility for our actions when they affect those around us-even if that means giving up a small degree of personal freedom.” I feel the same way. And your “reservation” on a “quiet working environment” at the expense of my free use of tools commonly used at our condominium is simply unacceptable to me. It is assumptive and harrassing. Especially when earplugs and soundproofing options are just as easy for you and you don’t need my permission to use them.
I believe each man must be free to do what is his duty as he defines it, so long as he does not use force against another. I also believe each man to be ultimately responsible for what happens to him. True, he is influenced by his heredity, his environment, his subconscious, and by pure chance. But I insist that precisely what makes man man is his ability to rise above these influences, to change and determine his own destiny. If this be true, then it follows that each of us is terribly and inevitably and forever responsible for everything he does. We are all imperfect in our knowledge of the ultimate purpose of our lives, imperfect in his choice of means to serve those purposes he does select, imperfect in the integrity with which he deals with himself and those around him, imperfect in his capacity to love his fellow man. If man is imperfect, then all of his constructs must be imperfect, and the choice is always among degrees and kinds of imperfection. Utopia is never going to be realized here on earth, and the man who insists that it is, is always lost unto freedom.
Moreover, man’s imperfections are intensified as he acquires the power to coerce others; “power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely.” This completes the listing of my assumptions, and it should be clear that the list does not constitute a total philosophy of life. Most importantly, it does not define what I believe the free man’s duty to be, or more specifically, what I believe my own duty to be and the source of the charge to me.
By the way, I had 15 cuts each lasting approximately 1 minute spread over about an hour and a half. That’s about 15 minutes of saw noise. Last Saturday, there were no less than 3 electric saws going in our neighborhood, one of them directly across from your apartment, and another in the parking area, not to mention the construction at the new Wallgreen?s. It seemed like a good day to get the noise out of the way. I wonder how many OTHER letters you sent out on Friday?
Oh, by the way, I personally really LIKE saw noise myself. It reminds me of the sound of progress and value and change and allows me to forget about the overbearing self-righteous jerks whose own intrusive unilateral behavior interferes with my personal life in a negative way. I work very hard during the week and find a weekend filled with electric saw using to be very relaxing.
And please don’t ever put any notes like that on my door again, it was really childish, if there is something you don’t like about me, just confront me in personlike a mature adult.
And here’s my official answer…..
My Best Low Road Rebuttal # 2: Ok, this is what I really meant to say
October 23,2003 Bob, I need to bring to your attention something that occurs every damn day several times a day. I’ve never spoken to you about this but I made the mistaken assumption that you had a brain. Due to the nature of MY WORK I demand absolute silence from all those within 326.34 feet from my left ear and 567.34 yards from my right ear. I must tell you that due to the nature of my tough job for a famous cult which will go unmentioned, as worlds foremost slackmaster, as well as my eccentric and arbitrary nature, that my privacy is more important to me than gold or diamonds or the riches men lay by and store up for some far, far distant , yet unrealized, time. OK this is it, man. Here’s how I “feel”. Too bad you forced me to tell you. You stomp around at all hours of the day or night like a lost herd of drunken water buffaloes careening from wall to wall stumbling aimlessley around your APARTMENT all the while mumbling incoherently in a gravelly hate-filled tone along with the incessant combined breathing, and sweating sounds you make. I never heard anyone sweat before. Not to mention the nocturnal squirting and farting sounds emanating from the direction of what I can only presume to be your bedroom. This constant noise is just too disruptive and is patently unnacceptable Although you appear to be just a loser ex-hippie who is only able to hold down a part-time teaching job at a local adult learning center teaching software to wasted losers which a normal child can learn right out of the box., you do seem capable of regular thought processes. I understand that you give “readings” by telephone whatever that means. I guess you somehow deduce the psychic aura or ass gasses of your “customers” through the telephone line and then proceed to tell them whatever will get them to pay you some money all the while making yourself “feel” like you are helping some poor soul. What a racket you clowns have. I always been too embarrassed too stoop that low. Maybe only mugging old blind women and having sex with dead farm animals would be slightly less honorable. I will never give you at any time some advance notice so you can arrange a time in your schedule when you could be away and I could feel free to do my work. I always feel free to do my work. That would be redundant and illogical and irresponsible to ascede my power to you. I will never give you a copy of my work schedule and I never want you watching me that closely, religiously following my routine and knowing what I do because my privacy is important to me and I’ve spent a lifetime protecting it from intrusive unilateral assholes such as yourself. I never felt we had an understanding nor do I want to have one. And besides, that’s just creepy. I never felt “disrespected” and I would never use that faddish term just because I hear it in the media like you do. One CAN’T be disrespected. It’s technically impossible. You can’t DEMAND respect from anyone. You can only EARN someone’s respect by displaying attributes of character worth respecting. God, Oh how I hate people who use that term like you did. As far as trust is concerned, why would you ever feel like you could trust me? What kind of “world”do you live in. We live in a place where we don’t have to trust anyone. Why would I trust anyone I have no respect for? Please understand this is not personal, I will never let you into my life enough to earn my trust or respect but that was never a possibility for you anyway. You just live these illusions apparently about what your expectations are from your fellow man. And it’s entirely in your head. This issue will never resurface because I will never treat you as an equal to me, again. By leaving that letter on my door, you have self-selected yourself out of my “sphere of caring”. Thanks for saving me the trouble. There won’t be any confusion about my position. In the future, I would appreciate it if you would just stab your self in the eye whenever you want to make a noise. No amount of reasonable notice that you are planning to make noise will ever work to my benefit. You are never welcome to call to set things up. Though they can speak for themselves, I could care less if you consider the other neighbors. That’s their business. Allegedly, Sara works at night and I wouldn’t be so presumptuous as usurping what is hers and hers alone, her opinion. Worth no more or less than yours. She’s probably trying to sleep when you are stomping around and beeping your burglar alarm, but I wouldn’t know that either. Maybe you should ask her. Jeff works at a very difficult job (I wouldn’t know, and I don’t care to find out) and presumably prizes his privacy as much as you and I do, but t’s none of my business. The other thing that happened at least four times a day, every day of the year because you don’ go out too much is that you always activate and deactivate your remote control car burglar alarm system with 3 beeps. I hear those three beeps so many times I can imitate them in my sleep. I can’t tell you how many times those 3 beeps have woken me up from a sound sleep — beep-beep-beep, there it is right now. Don’t you hear it? Have you ever stopped to think it might be irritating and intrusive? NEVER! NO just beep-beep-beep , beep-beep-beep , beep-beep-beep , all the time. Everyday, but do I ever complain, NO!!! I turn my stereo up loud enough so that I can hear my music while I work outside. I WORK ON MY HOUSE!!! Get used to it! You should listen to my music, it is so much better than the shit you listen to. Oh my God, what was that, Helen Reddy? Your music is crap. You should get some wireless headphones and just wear them whenever you are at home constantly barraging you with an endless stream of relaxation tapes intermiixed with Tangerine Dream and other hippie shit. I glad you try to keep the volume low out of respect for me and the neighbors, but it’s still shitty music. Never mention my daughter again. You’re not allowed to. You don’t have that level of privelege. I’m not willing to work with you on this at all I believe you just need to chill and learn to appreciate being my neighbor. Fuck all that insulation and soundproofing and all that stuff — that’s just a red herring. I don’t want you telling me what to do and I don’t give a shit about you enough to tell you what to do.. That crap about you working a lifetime?! On what!? You are a classic underachiever. The stuff you call work doesn’t really count That’s not real work. That flim-flam stuff is going to get you in trouble, eventually. You may as well be a bus boy. It’d pay more. Don’t make assumptions about my former life, either I hate that shit. You don’t know what I’;ve been through and don’t assume anything. You are just really too restrictive, arbitrary, assumptive, and naive. You have way too many expectations on your environment and the behavior of the people around you. We don’t have to communicate with each other and we don’t have to respect each other’s privacy beyond that which is protected by the rule of law. I never agree to giving up any measure of personal freedom for any price My experience is that intrusive unilateral behavior like yours always leads to negative relationships with me. That leads to tension and conflict and you better not be threatening me. The following is the most true statement of your letter: ” realize these are my values and you may not agree with them”. That is absolutely true. I am not open to any discussion regarding the contents of this letter and/or whatever you may deem to be reasonable, shared, solutions. I’m not into sharing and caring. I am not willing to work with you. This last statement made me laugh!!!! Real hard!!! “I also want to make it absolutely clear that I am firm in the preservation of my privacy. It will not waver from day to day, hour to hour; and neither will my respect for the privacy of the others around me. Both are constants and both are core values that I have worked a lifetime to develop” Yeah, sure like nobody else does. God, what trite bullshit! Where did you learn to write? You know what I hate — the concept of fairness — it constrains natural selection and leads to a muddy gene poo
What I Read That He Said # 3
October 23,2003 Steve, I need to bring to your attention something that occurred last Saturday morning that you did that really pissed me off a whole lot. I had previously yelled at you about the obscene noise from all of your many power saws and other noisy and probably unnecessary equipment and such. I expressed to you that due to the secret esoteric nature of my important work, as well as my overall eccentric lifestyle, my privacy was very important to me and that your confounded noise was absolutely too disruptive and just not acceptable. You seemed to be conscious and aware of your surroundings and seemed to understand that the saws could be awfully, painfully loud and that they could be damaging to listen to. I scolded you and reprimanded you and belabored the point to you at that time that if you would ask my permission, in advance, I might see if, maybe, I could possibly arrange a time in my busy schedule when I could be away for a very short time and you could feel free to make all the noise you want, sawing boards for no apparent reason but for some reason you seem to find so much joy. I gave you a copy of my mysterious and important super secret work schedule. I felt we had an understanding, a bond, an ironclad contract. Last Saturday, for some unknown reason, all that I had gone on and on about for a long damn time was simply disregarded. You just went ahead with your sawing anyway with no thought of your fellow man as if I had never held a discussion with you about it. I felt disrespected, cheap, screwed over and naturally you’ve blown any chance you ever had of me ever trusting you or allowing you to have me as a friend. The worst part of it is that if you had just gotten down on your knees and approached me on your belly, grovelling, beforehand, as I had instructed you to, I would have told you that I was leaving for Lake Tahoe the very next day and would be far, far, away Sunday, Monday and Tuesday. If only you had listened to me, this issue would not have resurfaced. Since it has come up again, I am making sure I put it in writing so even an idiot like you will be able to understand and there will never, ever again be any chance of confusion about the way you must act when you are around me. In the future, you must give me six weeks notice that you are planning to use the saws and I will see if I will allow you. My phone number is [removed], but please don’t call me unless you are ready to concede to all of my demands. Then you can call me between the hours of 1:00 pm and 2:00 pm and maybe I will set things up with you. I do the speaking for our neighbors too so I also know their needs and can offer any apologies you may have in their behalf. I know that Sara works at night and was trying to sleep while you were sawing. She probably was crying and rolling over and generally being pissed off, I’d imagine. Jeff works at a very, very difficult and also a super-secret job and prizes his privacy as much as I’m certain that he didn’t come out on his deck last Saturday just to say “Hello”; In fact, he was going to tell you, “Shut the fuck up!”, but I was able to talk him down and calm his animal rage being the wonderful natural negotiator that I am. Another one of the long list of things I hate about you is that last Saturday you turned your stereo up so loud it was even louder than your saws, it was louder than a 747 next to my ear. If you turn it up that loud, you can be sure that I am dying from the pain of your shitty music. I love music but believe you me, I would interfere with someone’s right to play it when it’s not even music but just some shit, but that crap you call music makes me projectile vomit. Why not Elton or Olivia Newton John, or St. John Denver, (God bless his sainted mop) anything, something with a beat. But that stuff you play sounds like the pitiful screaming of lost souls roasting in Hell. I don’t think it’s unreasonable to want to listen to my own music when it’s being recycled through a floor. I play my stereo on the average forty-five hours a day, every day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year. I keep the volume completely off out of respect for my neighbors, but using my superior intellect I am still able to mentally derive extreme quantities of satisfaction from the music. Whenever you have one of your two friends or whatever you call them, over, however few they may be, or your daughter, everyone talks so loud and the stereo and TV are turned up so loud I just about go nuts. It makes it hard for me to eavesdrop on your private and intimate conversations. I could recite your entire conversations all day long, verbatim. I really like to overhear your private conversations in this way. You probably know that I have a great interest in hearing them, you loser. Again, I’m willing to determine and adjust the level of sound in your house. I could experiment with different volume levels. Another idea might be to put some insulation board or soundproofing up on the ceiling above the stereo equipment. I soundproofed one of my bedrooms for a roommate because he was just too damn loud all the time, too, and I needed more privacy to conduct my special experiments. I thought it worked out great and did’nt cost my roommate but half of his life savings. I’ll show you the soundproofing I have and how I attached it. (In all fairness, other than last Saturday, I have noticed a drop in the Stereo/TV volume and have appreciated it greatly but it was probably only because you went out of town or something like that). Maybe you have been used to living in a gigantic mansion, with servants, and lots of space around you to play your so-called music and a sound-proofed shed to deaden the hideous, frightful noise of your saws. I don’t know, but here, I think we have six units and around 30 or 40 people in about the same space as a closet. I believe it is important that everyone communicate with me and pay me homage and respect my privacy. I also feel that you need to take responsibility for your actions when they affect me. I believe, in time, you will gladly give up your personal freedom to me. My experience is that if you don’t obey my rules, then my intrusive unilateral behavior will always lead to a negative relationship with you. That will lead to tension and conflict with you. Soon, your home will not be safe from my wrath. It sure won’t feel like “Home” to you anymore. I hope you realize these are my values and although you may not agree with them, you will get used to them in time. I just wanted to give you fair warning and let you know where I’m coming from. I am not open to any discussion regarding the contents of this letter or any reasonable, shared, solutions. I am willing only to work with you in the ways I’ve stated. I also want to make it absolutely clear that I am firm in the preservation of my privacy. It will not waver from day to day, hour to hour; week to week, year to year, decade to decade,and neither will my intolerance for those who do not respect my sacred privacy and unrealistic expectations of others that are my birthright. Both are constants and both are core values that I have worked many lifetimes and on many planes of consciousness to develop.
